Hosta collection at OpdeHaar gardens

Hosta sieboldiana Elegans
Hosta sieboldiana Elegans

On this page about the hosta collection at OpdeHaar there is information about:

Hostas – undemanding

Especially for a shade garden, the hosta is an invaluable plant. Together with hemerocallis (day-lily) and heuchera, it is a species that is a favourite with American hybridisers and many variants consequently have their origins in The New World. That said, The Netherlands boasts one of the larger specialist nurseries – Fransen in Ter Aa, where all of the varieties of hosta seen in our gardens are to be found. People interested in a more systematic look at the hosta varieties are recommended to visit a national collection notably that in Arboretum Trompenburg (Rotterdam) where varieties are conveniently planted in alphabetical order.   Hosta are very undemanding in their cultivation requirements but if there is one big secret to keeping them happy, it is that they should NEVER be allowed to dry out around the roots. Persistent dryness caused by increasing competition from expanding roots of adjacent trees or shrubs or expanding leaf canopies or any sort of drought is one of the few things that can cause the loss of a plant. The reason I make something of a point of this is that I have experienced it myself. Hosta are the prototype “tough cookies” when it comes to cultivation requirements but you will notice how they literally shrink during a dry summer and will be noticeably smaller the next year after a drought. If you decide to set about growing the Hosta giants such as Empress Wu or Sum and Substance, spring-feeding, good mulching and a moist soil are especially vital to ensure show-stopping plants. Unless you are prepared to water regularly, don’t subject both yourself and the hosta to the misery of planting in dry soils.

All the photos were taken in our garden.

Hosta types

For the non-specialist, we focus on 4 types of hosta characteristics.

Large (giant) plants and / or leaves, such as Hosta “Sum and Substance”

Decorative leaves

Small plants and/or leaves e.g Hosta “Little Wonder”

Scented Flowers

Another characteristic could be scented flowers but flowers are arguably secondary to other hosta attributes and we have never selected plants for their flowers, although in August they can put on a good display.  There are some people who deliberately remove flowers from hosta because they regard them as distractions on a foliage plant. That is a matter of taste but attention has been given to the fact that some hosta flowers are distinctly scented. The classic scented species is Hosta plantaginea but for those interested in taking it further, the internet has many references but an excellent general review, entitled “Fragrant Hosta’s”  is that provided by Tony Avent.

Red Hostas – The equivalent of the “black tulip”

Increasing numbers of hosta with red stems (petioles) have been introduced in recent years and occasionally some of this pigmentation extends a little into the base of the leaf.

The proverbial “Holy Grail” is now a hosta which clearly has red/purple colouration over a significant proportion, if not all, of its leaf area. There is a very informative history of this saga by Donald Rawson on the Hosta Lists website which is also an excellent reference for numerous other hosta characteristics – 

Bob Solberg of Green Hill Farm nursery in USA is a prominent hosta hybridiser working to achieve this and in 2009 he introduced Hosta “Beet Salad” which has a thin red rim around the leaf edges in spring. He used this in his hybridisation programme to develop Hosta “First Blush” which represents the first major breakthrough in the search for red leaf hosta. The following text and photo are taken from his Green Hill Farm nursery website:

( 48/49 seedling X “Beet Salad”) Medium ( 12 X 24 “) “First Blush” not only has green leaves with red petioles that extend into the leaf blade but also a thin red margin around the leaf, similar but much more dramatic than its parent “Beet Salad”. However, the most exciting thing about “First Blush” is that in spring the leaf between the veins will start to “blush”red  from the tip of the leaf down toward the base. The leaves remain red here until temperatures surpass 92F degrees, usually in June. The color should persist longer in Northern gardens. Our first red-leaved hosta. We do plan to patent this hosta.

Solberg 2015

As I write these lines in June 2016, limited supplies of “Red Blush” are on sale here in the Netherlands and Bob’s photo is indeed representative of what is on offer. Red/purple colouration in plants arises from anthocyanin derivatives and, in the case of hosta, has attracted attention in the sense of published material more in the context of very dark flower colouration than in leaf pigmentation. That said, Solberg himself has outlined something of what has driven his efforts. See:

To judge from recurring remarks in the literature, one major barrier which needs to be overcome is to achieve some stability or persistence of the anthocyanin compound(s) in the leaf. Elevated temperatures seem to indicate thermal instability – Solberg states > 92 deg F or 33 deg C as critical and postulates that performance in cooler climates is therefore a reasonable expectation. In view of the fact that anthocyanin-related colouration is fairly widespread in the plant kingdom and even on hosta petioles, it isn’t unreasonable to expect that improved red/purple pigmentation will eventually be achieved. The possible mechanisms involved are beyond the scope of this website and could even extend to changes in the photosynthesis mechanism as temperatures rise.  It would be tempting to see to what, if any, extent putting a plant at, say, 22 deg C could restore the red leaf colouration and exploring this pigmentation phenomenon could constitute an enormously interesting and educative research topic for a young botanist! In January 2018, Solberg’s patent for a Hosta plant named “First Blush” was published by the US Patent Office under the number PP 28920.

The challenges I’ve just summarized were taken up by Doug Ruff in Minnesota who registered Hosta “Bloodline” in 2019 but he chose not to apply for a patent. However, he has published valuable insights into his hybridisation plan which led to his breakthrough in prolonging the period of the blush – Hosta “Bloodline” is reasonably easy to find in Europe but is still on the pricey side! It is noteworthy that the red colouration is improved by planting in a fairly sunny position which is consistent with one function of anthocyanin production as a protective sunscreen for young leaves. 


Slug Damage

Slug damage deters more gardeners from having a hosta collection than any other factor and has achieved a folkloric status akin to statements such as “Bamboo will take over the garden”! While it is true that an untreated heavy slug infestation can eventually reduce hosta to a selection of tattered stumps and leaves reminiscent of open lace, this can be fairly easily prevented and references on the Internet or via The Hosta Library go into detail on the topic. That all said, when we started our gardens, we certainly suffered from holes in hosta leaves and had to use slug pellets but the need for this control has diminished over the years such that we frequently never have to resort to slug control measures.

Natural control by birds, amphibians and predators

We seem to achieved a natural level of control thanks to birds, amphibians and predators such as hedgehogs. Nonetheless, we do keep a close eye on new hosta shoots emerging in the Spring and treat very sparingly with slug pellets at any first sign of damage. When/If this happens, I often repeat the treatment after about 3 weeks – the theory is that this will deal with any hatching slug eggs! A discussion on slug control can easily fill a book and there are articles in plenty on the Internet but, based on comments frequently made by visitors to the garden, it is worth highlighting a few items.


A slug slides along and anything you do to render this inconvenient will help – mulches of cinders or small wood chips around the plants come to mind. Providing a lethal but attractive alternative to a hosta meal such as a beer trap in which a slug will drown is another approach. A biological control involves introducing nematodes which are parasitic on slugs into the soil.

Balance of efficacy and convenience

However, in my experience, the use of slug pellets provides the optimal balance of efficacy and convenience but some words of caution are appropriate. A basic slug pellet consists of an edible slug attractant impregnated with a poison; manufacturers augment these ingredients with additives to provide some level of shower-proofing, a deterrent to render pellets unattractive to mammals and birds which mistake them for food and usually a colourant so you can see them. The cardinal rule for using pellets is to use them sparingly around the hosta – you don’t need many. I often tell visitors that the object is to kill slugs in your garden and not to throw a party for everything in surrounding gardens (remember the “attractant” ingredient). 

Metaldehyde pellets

The traditional slug pellet contains an organic chemical called metaldehyde at 3 to 4% levels. This ruptures the slime glands of a slug which soon dies leaving a very visible trail so you know the pellet has worked! Metaldehyde degrades safely once in the environment so, especially when it rains heavily or frequently, you need to keep an eye on things and maybe repeat the treatment. The chemical metaldehyde itself is toxic to birds and mammals so if your dog or child decides to make a meal of the pellets, it will certainly get a tummy ache. Fortunately metaldehyde soon breaks down and symptoms are usually temporary with no persisting problems. Hence the use of additives rendering pellets unpleasantly bitter in the mouth. That said, the use of metaldehyde in garden slug control products because of toxicity risks to mammals/birds will be banned in UK from 2020.

Iron pellets

Ferric ( iron) phosphate is widely promoted as an alternative to metaldehyde; it is not toxic when ingested by warm-blooded creatures. It functions by disrupting the digestive system of the slug which basically crawls back under ground and dies but without leaving a handy visible trace in contrast to metaldehyde. Moreover, the efficacy of an iron phosphate pellet is enhanced when it is moist. In short, it seems to provide the ideal alternative to metaldehyde. The fact that the active substance necessarily involves a chelating agent (EDTA) alongside the iron phosphate to enhance the uptake of iron escaped the initial attention of health and safety legislators. Iron itself is essential in our bodies, and EDTA is used in many medicines, but like many other chemicals, when taken in huge quantities they can be dangerous. From the gardener’s perspective, the bottom line is that, just as with medicines, use any garden pesticide with care and read the small print on the bottle or can. Pellets are perfectly safe when used properly.

Propogation of hostas

Bulking up” or increasing the number of hosta variants is classically done by splitting up the crowns as plants emerge in the spring. If you select plants at a garden centre or nursery having several crowns or growing points, you can, in our experience, wash the soil off the roots and cut plants into several sections at any time during the growing season. However, a lot of our bulking up comes from potting up seedlings, which are very numerous around many of our plants. Technically speaking, most if not all seedlings from hybrids are individually new varieties although visually they are often indistinguishable from their parents. (This is in contrast to aquilegia when several varieties are planted in close proximity.) For example in the Millennium Garden,  all the hosta down the side of the ditch are seedlings from Hosta sieboldiana “Elegans”,which they resemble with the exception of around 5 which seem to have a more golden leaf.


It is a bit of a game with us to grow many seedlings on in the hope that we may discover a worthwhile “sport” – a plant with a difference, which is commercially interesting! Anybody who reads a book on hosta varieties cannot fail to be struck by the large numbers of varieties that arise as “sports”. In other words, in total contrast to work with plants such as roses and rhododendrons, where new hybrids are often the result of careful and calculated crosses, new hosta hybrids are largely arrived at by chance. I find this rather hard to believe but it is true.

The relative flood of new hosta introductions suggests that there is some interesting scope for anyone prepared to set about some deliberate hybrid crosses. When I raised this subject with a leading hosta nurseryman, he pointed out that tissue culture was increasingly used to propagate new stock and that chemicals and hormones used to get new plants going must, in his view, contribute to the extensive sport formation.

At the risk of bruising the sensibilities of some hosta fanatics, I often think how very similar a lot of the otherwise lovely varieties are – particularly from the point of view of someone primarily interested in their decorative value in the garden. Similarities are not at all surprising when one delves into the origins of the varieties since, particularly where sports are involved, I assume that a novel leaf colour or variegation arises because a normally recessive gene becomes “activated” for some reason and is then acceptably stable for subsequent propagation. If one starts with a basic set of genes as in H. Fortunei  which is in all probability itself a complex hybrid, the Hyacintha” variant has given rise to several sports which in turn have sported. A sport arises as a result of shuffling a given series of genes. If this process occurs frequently and repeatedly, it would be surprising if the results did not give virtually identical sports on occasions. For example, “Hyacintha” sported to give “Francee which then gave rise to “Patriot. More recently, “Patriot” sported to give “Loyalist while “Francee produced “Fire ‘n Ice”. “Loyalist and “Fire ‘n Ice in our garden are as identical as one can get. With no disrespect intended to the nurserymen involved with these two sports, I do wonder if a more critical filter on new named varieties wouldn’t be helpful. Cutting a long story short, it seems an area of hosta culture that would be interesting to follow up. Joining a Hosta Club or Society  would be a good starting point.    

Hosta Virus X (HVX)

About a decade ago, it was realised that the discolouration and mottling of leaves on some hosta’s was caused by a virus which is now called “hosta virus X” or simply HVX . It is very serious because it is easily spread by slight mechanical damage while handling infected plants and will weaken and eventually kill hosta’s. There is a lot of information on the Internet under a search of “HVX, hosta” with pictures of infected plants. The virus cannot survive in the soil so the total removal of a plant including every bit of root followed by thoroughly cleansing the hands should be OK for most gardeners. The situation is orders of magnitude more serious for nurseries and holders of collections because the virus can be so easily transmitted and one visibly infected plant can imply that the whole of a collection is infected because symptoms can take a few seasons to manifest themselves. Finally in this last context, our major Dutch hosta nursery with significant international trade, Fransen operates a very rigorous (and costly!) joint testing programme to ensure as far as practically possible that their plants are free of virus.

Our hosta collection

For more photos of hostas in our garden see the photo below


There are countless numbers of hosta varieties available and they increase almost daily. For people wanting some quick visual references on the internet, there are two very good links that I can suggest:


Scroll to Top